TRACKING POLYCHLORINATED BIPHENYLS IN THE MILLERS RIVER BASIN, MASSACHUSETTS
By Bruce E. Taggart, John A. Colman, and Matthew G. Cooke
Fact Sheet 093-03
During the summer and fall of 1999, the U.S. Geological Survey measured polychlorinated biphenyl (PCB) concentrations in passive samplers deployed in the Millers River Basin in Massachusetts. The observed PCB concentrations and congener-pattern changes indicated a historical release of PCBs likely occurred on the Otter River at the upstream margin of Baldwinville, Massachusetts. PCB concentrations decreased significantly downstream of the confluence of the Otter River with the Millers River because of dilution of Otter River water with mostly uncontaminated water from the Millers River and volatilization of PCBs in steep reaches of the Millers River. The PCB load in the Millers River was relatively small compared with PCB loads in other PCB-contaminated rivers in the Northeast. The likely source of PCBs in the Millers River Basin is the remobilization of PCBs associated with stream sediments. PCBs deposited on the sediment likely originated from an upstream source. Estimated concentrations of PCBs in water throughout the main stems of the Millers and Otter Rivers exceeded the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s water-quality criterion, which is based on the cancer risk associated with eating fish taken from the water. PCB concentrations detected in indicator fish (white suckers; Catostomus commersoni) sampled in 2000 were four times less than concentrations detected in the same species sampled in 1985-88.
Figure 1. A U.S. Geological Survey research scientist deploys a passive water-column sampler in the Otter River, Massachusetts.
In March 1999, the U.S. Geological Survey (USGS), in cooperation with the Massachusetts Executive Office of Environmental Affairs Millers River Watershed Team and the Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection, began an investigation of PCBs in the Millers River and one of its tributaries, the Otter River. The purposes of the study were
• to determine the source(s) of elevated PCB concentrations observed in 85 fish-tissue samples from 12 fish species in both rivers during earlier investigations by the Massachusetts Division of Water Pollution Control and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (ENSR Corporation, 2000), and
• to establish the extent of fish exposure to PCBs along the main stem of the Millers and Otter Rivers in Massachusetts.
This Fact Sheet discusses the results of this investigation. It also presents annual loads of PCBs passing the USGS stream-gaging station in South Royalston on the Millers River (USGS stream-gaging station 01164000) and discusses concentrations of PCBs found in fish samples. More detailed information about the study results and data-collection methods can be found in Colman (2001).
Figure 2. Passive-sampler deployment and fish-sampling sites, mean polychlorinated biphenyl (PCB) concentrations, and change in congener patterns along the Millers and Otter Rivers, Massachusetts. PCB concentrations increased and congener patterns changed in the downstream direction beginning at river mile O-35.2. In this study, a river mile refers to the distance from the confluence of the Millers River with the Connecticut River to the sampling station, as measured along the river channel. The sampling station is named with the first letter of the river on which the station is located and the river mile. For example, the sampling station on the Otter River that is 36.2 miles from the confluence of the Millers River with the Connecticut River is named O-36.2.
Where Do PCBs Originate?
Although PCBs generally accumulate in sediments, it is the dissolved form that enters bacteria and plants at the lowest level of the food web (Colman, 2001). In this study, passive water-column samplers were deployed in the Millers and Otter Rivers to estimate dissolved PCB concentrations in river water (fig. 1). Results from these samplers, which absorbed PCBs over a 2-week period, were obtained at 26 stations in the Millers and Otter Rivers (figs. 1 and 2), to identify the reaches most likely to be source areas leading to exposure of fish to dissolved PCBs (Colman, 2001).
The PCBs absorbed by these samplers were quantified in terms of congenersindividual PCB compounds. The congener patterns of Aroclors, mixtures of PCB congeners that were produced commercially, are the source of the congener patterns currently present in stream samples. By analyzing PCBs in terms of their congener patterns, researchers can “fingerprint” PCB sources and track the movement of PCBs in the environment. Congener patterns are unlikely to be exactly the same in samples from different sources; therefore, significant changes in these patterns, or fingerprints, within a river reach can indicate additional sources of PCBs (U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, 2002a).
Changes in PCB concentrations and PCB-congener patterns between sampling stations can be quantified and were determined by using a statistic referred to as the root-mean-square difference (RMSD). The RMSD measures the difference in normalized congener patterns between pairs of samples at a particular sampling site or between sampling sites, such as the next sampling site immediately upstream (Colman, 2001).
In addition to the passive-sampler survey, average daily loads of PCB congeners were calculated from composite river-water samples collected at a USGS stream-gaging station in South Royalston, MA (USGS stream-gaging station 01164000). In 2000, white suckers (Catostomus commersoni) were collected at four sites and their tissue analyzed for total PCB concentration as Aroclors. These data were compared to fish-tissue data from white suckers collected in 1985-88 (fig. 3).
Figure 3. Polychlorinated biphenyl concentrations in fish tissue sampled from the Millers and Otter Rivers, Massachusetts. Concentrations in fish were four times less is samples collected in 2000 than in samples from previous studies.
PCBs in the Environment
Clear trends were present in the PCB distribution resulting from the passive-sampler analyses (Colman, 2001). In the Otter River, PCB concentration increased substantially in the downstream direction, beginning at river mile O-35.2, with the greatest concentration measured in the entire basin occurring between river miles O-32.1 and O-31.2 (fig. 2). The maximum change in the PCB-congener pattern, as indicated by statistical analysis of sample results, was determined to be farther upstream, between river miles O-36.2 and O-35.2. Also, a large relative increase in PCB concentrations in the Otter River coincided with the pattern change between river miles O-36.2 and O-35.2.
Below the confluence of the Otter River with the Millers River, PCB concentrations decrease by a factor of four (Colman, 2001). Dilution from the relatively uncontaminated upstream Millers River most likely causes this decrease. In steeper gradient, more turbulent sections of the river (river miles M-27.5 to M-21.0 and M-8.0 to M-0.1; fig. 4), volatilization, the escape of PCBs from water into the air, may also account for the decrease in concentrations.
Figure 4. A section of turbulent water on the Millers River, Massachusetts, at river mile M-26.5. As the river tumbles through these steep sections, dissolved PCBs can escape from the water into the air.
Commercial manufacturing of PCBs in the United States ended in 1977; therefore, measured concentrations of PCBs in the study area are not likely to be a result of active discharge. Instead, current concentrations probably come from PCBs associated with stream sediments or sediment deposited along the Millers and Otter Rivers. As PCBs discharge into a river, they attach to fine-grained sediment suspended in the water column. These particles move downstream with the flowing water and ultimately settle in reaches of the river where the gradient decreases or in slack pools. Eventually, the PCBs that accumulate in the sediment may leach from the sediment back into the water column. This process is likely responsible for the current PCB concentrations in water samples from the Millers and Otter Rivers.
Immediately downstream of river mile O-33.1, the gradient of the Otter River decreases. Over the years, fine-grained sediments have settled in this reach of the river, which is characterized by riparian wetlands. Apparently, the PCBs in these sediments are now leaching back into the water, as indicated in results obtained from applying the RMSD method to PCB concentrations and changes in PCB-congener patterns at consecutive sampling stations (Colman, 2001).
If the present-day source of PCBs to the water-column source is contaminated streambed sediments, then the original source would be upstream of those sediments. The progressive increase of PCB concentrations downstream from river mile O-35.2, with the maximum pattern change between river miles O-36.2 and O-35.2, supports a hypothesized present-day PCB source that is within a downstream reach between river miles O-36.2 and O-31.2 (fig. 2). Examination of congener concentrations and congener patterns downstream of the Birch Hill Dam indicates no additional PCB sources to the Millers River, other than streambed sediments.
Different congeners result from substitution of chlorine atoms for hydrogen atoms on different carbon atoms on the biphenyl ring structure. Examples of a (A) higher-weight polychlorinated biphenyl molecule and a (B) lower-weight polychlorinated biphenyl molecule are shown in this diagram. In this study, the percentage of lower-weight congeners increased significantly from river mile O.36.2 to O-35.2 relative to higher-weight congeners.
In the Otter River, a large concentration increase and the greatest congener-pattern change occur between river miles O-36.2 and O-35.2. River mile O-35.2 is upstream from pipe outfalls in the community of Baldwinville, including the waste-water-treatment plant in Baldwinville that collects and treats waste from residences and industries in the community. Although pipe outlets and the treatment plant are downstream of the station at river mile O-35.2, sludge from the plant was placed in a landfill adjacent to the river upstream of the plant and upstream from the sampling station at mile O-35.2. The PCBs detected along this river reach may also have discharged to the Otter River before the wastewater-treatment plant began operating in 1979, may have existed in plant effluent after it commenced operation, or may have seeped into the river from sludge in the landfill (Colman, 2001).
Human Health Hazards of PCBs
The PCB load is the mass of dissolved PCBs and PCBs associated with suspended particulate matter passing by a specific point over a given time interval. The PCB load determined from samples collected by the USGS on the Millers River at South Royalston, MA (USGS stream-gaging station 01164000), was about 9 pounds per year. This result, distributed between the dissolved phase and suspended particulate matter, indicates that measurable amounts of PCBs continue to be transported downstream in the Millers River. Although the load was small when compared to loads in other PCB-contaminated rivers in the Northeast, such as the Housatonic River (Gay and Frimpter, 1984), concentrations in river water from South Royalston to the confluence of the Millers River with the Connecticut River were high enough to cause concern about PCB accumulation in fish tissue.
The USGS was able to estimate, as presented in Colman (2001), the amount of dissolved PCBs that might be available to fish by measuring the concentrations of PCBs collected by passive samplers. Estimated water-column concentrations varied from less than 1 ng/L (nanogram per liter), in upstream reaches of the Millers and Otter Rivers, to about 300 ng/L on the Otter River just upstream from the confluence with the Millers River. At the first station downstream of the confluence, at river mile M-29.1, the estimated concentration of dissolved PCBs decreased to about 60 ng/L. Downstream of river mile M-29.1, in the first turbulent section below the confluence, the estimated dissolved PCB concentrations were as low as about 10 ng/L and remained between roughly 10 and 20 ng/L to the confluence of the Millers River with the Connecticut River (Colman, 2001).
In 1992, the USEPA established a water-quality criterion for concentrations of PCBs in water of 0.044 ng/L on the basis of the cancer risk associated with eating fish taken from PCB-contaminated water. The USEPA subsequently reassessed the cancer risk and amended the criterion to 0.17 ng/L in December 1999 (Federal Register, 1999). Except for the upstream stations on the Millers and Otter Rivers, estimated concentrations in all reaches (more than 30 river miles) downstream from the maximum pattern change (from river mile O-36.2 to O-35.2) exceeded the USEPA’s water-quality criterion.
Why White Suckers?
Although the estimated fish-exposure levels exceeded the USEPA water-quality criterion through much of the study area during this investigation, PCB concentrations in fish, as determined by a survey of white suckers, have declined since earlier investigations were conducted. Concentrations of PCBs in fish-tissue samples collected in 2000 were four times less than concentrations found in samples collected from 198588 (Robert Maietta, Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection, written commun., 2001).
The decrease in PCB concentrations in fish since the earlier studies indicates that fish exposure to PCBs in the Millers River Basin is decreasing. This decrease is most likely the result of little or no additional PCBs recently entering the system and the gradual burial, degradation, and leaching of existing PCBs attached to the sediment.
The Millers River at the USGS South Royalston stream-gaging station where the PCB load data were collected.
ATSDR, 2003, Case studies in environmental medicinePCB toxicity: Washington D.C., U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Agency for Toxic Substances and
Disease Registry, Division of Health Education and Promotion, Publication No. ATSDR-HE-CS-2003-0001, 40 p.
Colman, J.A., 2001, Source identification and fish exposure for polychlorinated biphenyls using congener analysis from passive water samplers in the Millers River Basin, Massachusetts: U.S. Geological Survey Water-Resources Investigations Report 00-4250, 44 p.
ENSR Corporation, 2000, Site assessment report and risk characterization of PCBs at Birch Hill Reservoir, Royalston, Massachusetts: U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, New England District, Task Order 28, Contract DACW33-96-D-0004, variously paged.
Federal Register, 1999, Water quality standards; Establishment of numeric criteria for priority toxic pollutants; States’ complianceRevision of polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) criteria; Final rule: Washington D.C., Government Printing Office, 40 CFR, Part 131, p. 6118261196.
Gay, F.B., and Frimpter, M.H., 1984, Distribution of polychlorinated biphenyls in the Housatonic River and adjacent aquifer, Massachusetts: U.S. Geological Survey Open-File Report 84-588, 34 p.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, 2002a, PCBs and Chemistry: Accessed online August 15, 2002, at http://www.epa.gov/hudson/pcbs101.htm
_____, 2002b, Health Effects of PCBs: Accessed online August 16, 2002, at http://www.epa.gov/ opptintr/pcb/effects.html
State advisories are available on concentrations of PCBs that may be harmful to people in fish and waterfowl. For more information, contact the Massachusetts Department of Public Health, Bureau of Environmental Health Assessment at (617) 624-5757 or visit their Web site at http://www.state.ma.us/dph/beha/ and type polychlorinated biphenyls or PCBs into the DPH search frame.
For more information about this or other USGS investigations in Massachusetts, contact the Northborough District office at 1-800-696-4042 or visit our Web site at http://ma.water.usgs.gov/.
By Bruce E. Taggart, John A. Colman, and Matthew G. Cooke. Graphic design by Christine Mendelsohn.
This report is presented in Portable Document Format (PDF).
To view and print report you will need to use PDF Viewer or Adobe Acrobat Reader (available as freeware).
Users with visual disabilities can visit this site for conversion tools and information to help make PDF files more accessible.
PDF version of report (6 pages--7 MB)
The citation for this report, in USGS format, is as follows:
Taggart, B.E., Colman, J.A., Cooke, M.G., 2003, Tracking polychlorinated biphenyls in the Millers River Basin, Massachusetts: U.S. Geological Survey Fact sheet FS 093-03, 6 p.
For more information about USGS activities in Massachusetts-Rhode Island District, visit the USGS Massachusetts-Rhode Island Home Page.
|AccessibilityFOIAPrivacyPolicies and Notices|
|U.S. Department of the Interior, U.S. Geological Survey
Persistent URL: http://pubs.water.usgs.gov/fs09303
Page Contact Information: GS Pubs Web Contact
Last modified: Wednesday, January 09 2013, 07:35:59 PM