USGS

Estimated Recharge to the Madison and Minnelusa Aquifers in the Black Hills Area, South Dakota and Wyoming, Water Years 1931-98

By Janet M. Carter, Daniel G. Driscoll, and Ghaith R. Hamade

 

U.S. GEOLOGICAL SURVEY

Water Resources Investigation Report 00-4278

 


Prepared in cooperation with the

South Dakota Department of Environment and
Natural Resources and the West Dakota Water Development District

 


ABSTRACT

The Madison and Minnelusa aquifers are two of the most important aquifers in the Black Hills area. Long-term estimates of recharge to the Madison and Minnelusa aquifers are important for managing the water resources in the Black Hills area. Thus, annual recharge from streamflow losses and infiltration of precipitation on outcrop areas is estimated for water years 1931-98. All estimates are for recharge that contributes to regional ground-water flow patterns and that occurs in outcrop areas connected to the regional flow system. Estimates exclude recharge to outcrop areas that are isolated from the regional flow system, which generally results in ground-water discharge to area streams.

 

Streamflow recharge is calculated directly for 11 streams in the Black Hills area that have continuous-record gaging stations located upstream from loss zones, using available records of daily streamflow, against which estimated loss thresholds (from previous investigations) are applied. Daily streamflow records are extrapolated, when necessary, using correlations with long-term gages, to develop annual estimates of streamflow recharge for 1950-98.

 

Streamflow recharge is estimated for a number of smaller basins using loss thresholds for miscellaneous-record sites. Annual recharge estimates are derived from synthetic records of daily streamflow for 1992-98, which are based on drainage-area ratios applied to continuous-record gaging stations. Recharge estimates are further extrapolated for 1950-91, based on the average percentage of streamflow recharge contributed by these basins during 1992-98, relative to overall streamflow recharge.

 

Streamflow recharge also is estimated for small drainage areas with undetermined loss thresholds that are situated between larger basins with known thresholds. Estimates for 1992-98 are based on estimates of annual streamflow derived using drainage-area ratios, with assumed losses equal to 90 percent of annual streamflow. Recharge estimates also are extrapolated for 1950-91, based on the average percentage of streamflow recharge contributed by these basins.

 

Precipitation recharge for 1931-98 is estimated using relations between precipitation and streamflow (or basin yield) for representative gaging stations. Basin yields are first normalized, relative to drainage area, by expressing in inches per unit of drainage area. Yields are further converted to yield efficiencies, by dividing by precipitation on contributing drainage areas. Relations between yield efficiency and precipitation are identified, which are developed for use in generically estimating annual yield for given areas, based on average yield efficiency and annual precipitation. The resulting annual yield is used as a surrogate for estimating annual recharge from infiltration of precipitation on outcrop areas of the Madison and Minnelusa aquifers. Annual yield (or recharge) efficiencies are estimated to range from about 2 percent to in excess of 30 percent, with corresponding average annual recharge estimates ranging from 0.4 inch in the southern Black Hills to about 8.7 inches in the northwestern Black Hills.

 

Estimates of precipitation recharge for 1931-49 are used to estimate streamflow recharge for the same period, based on correlations between the two variables for 1989-98. Combined streamflow and precipitation recharge to both aquifers averaged about 344 ft3/s for 1931-98. Streamflow recharge averaged about 93 ft3/s, or 27 percent of combined recharge, and precipitation recharge averaged about 251 ft3/s, or 73 percent of combined recharge. Combined recharge ranged from 62 ft3/s in 1936 to 847 ft3/s in 1995. The lowest recharge amounts generally occurred during the 1930’s; however, a more prolonged period of low recharge occurred during 1947-61.

 

For 1931-98, average precipitation recharge to the Madison aquifer is about 3.6 inches, compared with 2.6 inches for the Minnelusa aquifer. However, recharge volumes to these aquifers are nearly identical because the outcrop area of the Minnelusa Formation is larger than the outcrop area of the Madison Limestone. Streamflow recharge to the Madison aquifer is presumed slightly larger than for the Minnelusa aquifer, primarily because of preferential recharge resulting from an upgradient location. Considering both precipitation and streamflow recharge, the Madison aquifer receives about 55 percent of combined recharge, relative to about 45 percent for the Minnelusa aquifer.

 

The western flank of the Black Hills is almost entirely dominated by precipitation recharge, because of the large outcrop areas of Madison Limestone and Minnelusa Formation and absence of perennial streams. Recharge along the southeastern flank of the Black Hills generally is dominated by streamflow recharge. The relative contribution from streamflow and precipitation recharge is highly variable along the northern and northeastern flanks of the Black Hills.

 


CONTENTS

Inside Title Pages and TOC (54 KB) -- 5 pages

Section -- 1 (185 KB) -- 4 pages

Abstract

Introduction

Purpose and Scope

Description of Study Area

Physiography, Land Use, and Climate

Section -- 2 (3.1 KB) -- 18 pages

Geologic Setting

Hydrologic Setting

Acknowledgments

Recharge Processes and General Methods for Quantifying Recharge

Previous Investigations

Recharge Processes

General Methods for Quantifying Recharge

Considerations Regarding Recharge Areas

Methods for Quantifying Streamflow Recharge

Methods for Quantifying Precipitation Recharge

Uncertainties Associated with Recharge Estimates

Streamflow Recharge

Section -- 3 (3.1 KB) -- 38 pages

Recharge from Gaged Streams

Continuous-Record Gaging Stations

Calculated Streamflow Recharge

Extrapolation of Streamflow Recharge Estimates

Miscellaneous-Record Measurement Sites

Recharge from Ungaged Streams

Summary of Streamflow Recharge, 1950-98

Precipitation Recharge

Yield Efficiency

Recharge Estimates

Combined Recharge, 1931-98

Summary

References

Section -- 4 (49 KB) -- 6 pages

Supplemental Information

 


Whole report (PDF, 6.4MB)-- 71 pages

(Download Acrobat reader)

 

Document Accessibility: Adobe Systems Incorporated has information about PDFs and the visually impaired. This information provides tools to help make PDF files accessible. These tools convert Adobe PDF documents into HTML or ASCII text, which then can be read by a number of common screen-reading programs that synthesize text as audible speech. In addition, an accessible version of Acrobat Reader 5.0 for Windows (English only), which contains support for screen readers, is available. These tools and the accessible reader may be obtained free from Adobe at Adobe Access.

 



U.S. Department of the Interior, U.S. Geological Survey
Persistent URL: http://pubs.water.usgs.gov/wri004278
Page Contact Information: GS Pubs Web Contact
Last modified: Thursday, September 01 2005, 02:21:08 PM
FirstGov button  Take Pride in America button