Leg2A - 1(Hilina slump)

K209: Papau seamount (M. Coombs ) Sept. 5, 2001

Results of Dive K209

Date: September 5, 2001
Place: Southwest side of the Papa'u Seamount, South of Kilauea
Observer: Michelle Coombs
Co-observers: Pete Lipman, Tom Sisson
Advisors: Eiichi Takahashi, Toshiya Kanamatsu

Purpose of Dive K209
Papa'u seamount is a NE-SW trending elongate ridge centered 15 km off the south coast of Hawaii, due south of Kilauea volcano. It is aligned with and helps define what is known as the transverse boundary, which marks the western edge of the Hilina slump. Several hypotheses exist regarding the origin of the seamount. One is that it is an anticlinal fold, composed of volcaniclastic sediments such as those of the lower bench (J. Morgan, unpublished manuscript). Based on bottom photographs, this rounded submarine topogrpahic high has also been interpreted as a massive sand-rubble landslide deposit derived from an embayment near the Kilauea shoreline (Fornari and Moore, 1979). There have been no dives to date on this enigmatic feature. The SW side of Papa'U is the steepest, providing ~1000 m of relief in <4km. For this reason, it is thought that this route will have the best chance of revealing sediment-free outcrop. We will observe the structure of the seamount, looking in particular for evidence of coherent, folded beds versus debris, as well as obtain samples for petrologic and geochemical study. This dive is being made in conjunction with two other dives on this leg: K-207, on a ridge below and to the south of Papa'u, and K-208, on a ridge ~15 km to the east.

Summary of dive
Kaiko landed on the bottom at 8:58 at a depth of 1679 m. The sea floor was covered in sediments and loose talus. Kaiko then began ascending, moving over mud and sand with varying amounts of talus. No outcrops were seen visually or with the sonar, despite an average slope of ~15?. There was very little microtopography, the slope being remarkably constant. Sampling of talus blocks occurred at four sites during this segment of the dive, at depths of 1715, 1639, 1534, and 1456 m. Of note were large boulders, many ~1m in diameter, that littered the slope amongst much more prevalent smaller debris. These boulders varied in roundness, perhaps becoming more rounded as depth decreased.
We first sighted in-place outcrop at 1404 m, in the form of a small spine of weakly indurated breccia. Two samples were taken (#s 5a and 5b) and a push core (red) of breccia matrix was obtained. The weak induration seen here may explain the absence of microtopography on the slope; the material is too weak to form large ridges or cliffs. The second unequivocal breccia outcrop was spotted at 1230 m, and we obtained two angular clasts from it (#s 8a and 8b).
The slope continued to be predominantly covered with mud and talus. We took two more talus samples at 1329 m (#s 6a and 6b). At 1286 m, a light-colored bedding plane (?) was seen at the top of a leftward-slopping decline. The fine-grained unit was sampled (#7) and placed in the lidded box for safe keeping. Later in the dive, at least two more outcrops of light-colored, fine-grained bands appeared, at 1035 m and 962 m. Clasts from just below the bands were sampled (#10 and #11, respectively). Unconformity, strike and dip.
Two very uniform, sediment-free talus slopes were crossed at 1172 and 1104 m. The upslope direction was right (NE) in both cases. These were almost identical in nature, consisting of angular, weathered blocks 20-40 cm in diameter. We sampled two blocks from the upper of the two slopes (#s 9a and 9b).
The upper 300 m of the dive covered mainly sediment and gravelly talus, with occasional large blocks. Many rounded, reddish (oxidized?) cobbles and boulders were recognized. Zooming in on several of these revealed that they appeared to be vesicular. Reddish loose clasts were collected at 889 m (#s 12a, 12b, and 12c). The topography in this area was less uniform than on the lower slopes. The dive track crossed numerous evenly spaced benches and gentle rises, at about 20 m spacing. These showed up very well on the sonar display. These trend NW-SE, parallel to the overall seamount structure.
The summit of the seamount was reached at 14:43 and 742 m, making this the shallowest dive on record for ROV Kaiko. We collected samples just below the summit (#s 13a, 13b, and 13c) before ascending at 14:57.
Twenty-five rock samples were collected during the course of the dive, as well as four piston cores. All of the rocks are basalt lavas. They vary in vesicularity, crystal content, and glass content. There was no systematic variation in clast type with elevation.

Video Highlights of K209

Time Depth Feature
10:59-11:05 1404 Outcrop: plant-covered spine of weakly indurated breccia. Sample site 5, push core of matrix taken (red)
11:27-11:33 1286 Outcrop: Weathered brown band may be shear zone or simply bedding plane in breccia. It is fine-grained and discontinuous, strikes roughly perpendicular to slope (NW), steeply dipping into slope. Sample site 7.
11:40 1254 Ascending narrow ridge that is probably in-place breccia
11:44-11:47 1230 Massive breccia outcrop on the left face of narrow ridge. Angular clasts, black sand matrix? White band is visible at top of ridge, with ~1m of material above it. Sample site 8.
12:15-12:17 1104 Very uniform talus field, descending to the left. No sediment cover. Sample site 9.
12:41-12:50 1035 Another light-colored irregular band. Again exposed on the left side of a ridge with about 1 m of black-sand-rich debris above it. Lighter-colored breccia below it.15 cm thick. Striking NW diping steeply NE. Sample site 10.
12:53 Stratification in sediments at the top of a small ridge. Black sand alternating with gravel-rich beds
13:03-13:10 962 Spine of breccia outcrop, jointed. All breccia to the left, black sandy looser debris to the right. Spine strikes N25E. Same configuration as last two white band sightings. Sample site 11.
14:43 742 On summit, sandy floor with small rock chips
Geologic observations and discussion
All of the exposed outcrop consisted of weakly indurated breccia. The overall topography of the west side of Papa'u is very consistent, lacking in cliffs or ridges, suggesting that weakly indurated breccia comprises much of the seamount. All of the clasts sampled from the breccia and talus (which probably had not traveled far from their source) are lavas which may be subaerially erupted rocks from Kilauea. Whether the brecciation observed on the seamount was completely caused by transport to its present location, or whether the landslide is composed of previously brecciated volcaniclastics, is unclear. There was no sign of volcaniclastic rocks or any well-bedded sedimentary layers that would produce strong seismic reflectors or be capable of forming an anticlinal structure.
A crude stratigraphy is recorded by the appearance of oxidized, rounded cobbles and boulders in the top 300m of the section. Such rounding of large clasts may occur in a wave cut coastline environment.
The series of benches and rises seen in the top ~300 m of the seamount may be the result of small slumps. A larger version of this is the 1350m depth ridge on the west side of Papa'u. Further evidence for such slumping may be the steeply dipping white beds seen at several points along the dive. They dip steeply into the slope and are parallel to the overall structure of Papa'u. If these beds resided near the top of the landslide breccia, they may have rotated to their present position by slumping of the unconsolidated material that appears to comprise Papa'u.
time depth (m) altitude (m) heading (degree) Narrative Sample
9:28 1679 2.3 3 Muddy floor with rock fragments
8:58 1756 2.1 355 On bottom muddy flat floor with many rocks
9:02 1726 2.7 357 Moving over muddy floor with scattered blocks
9:07 1717 3.1 357 Moving over muddy floor with rock fragments
9:11 1715 0.7 78 Muddy floor with rock fragments
9:12 1715 0.7 78 Sample #1a put in box 2 (talus) 1a
9:13 1715 0.6 67 Sample #1b put in box 2 (talus) 1b
9:15 1714 1.6 44 Eel
9:16 1714 1.6 44 Attempting green push core in muddy floor. PC 1
9:18 1798 1.9 358 Big block
9:21 1706 2.9 10 Muddy floor with rock fragments
9:23 1700 1.9 10 The slope is down leftward
9:32 1667 3.5 36 Muddy floor with many rock fragments
9:37 1657 2.2 337 Muddy floor with rock chips
9:42 1639 2.9 338 The slope is down leftward,
9:44 1639 2.8 33 Muddy floor with many rock fragments, debris
9:45 1639 1.7 30 Sample #2a put in box 3 (talus) 2
9:46 1639 1.6 39 Sample #2b put in box 3 (talus) 2b
9:49 1639 1.5 39 Attempting blue push core in the gravel. Scooped small rock chips using pushcore sampler PC 2
9:53 1623 2.5 14 Muddy floor with some rock chips
9:59 1603 1.6 357 Muddy floor with rock fragments
10:04 1588 1.8 347 Octopus
10:08 1585 2.3 3 Muddy floor with rock chips
10:16 1559 3.7 357 Muddy floor with rock fragments
10:20 1549 1.6 3 Eel, shrimp
10:27 1534 0.7 20 Muddy floor with block, big fish
10:29 1534 0.7 20 Sample #3a put in box 4 (talus) 3a
10:30 1532 0.9 28 Sample #3b put in box 4 (talus) 3b
10:34 1532 2.3 348 Muddy floor with rock chips
10:40 1471 1.7 1 Muddy floor with rock chips
10:43 1455 2.3 19 Muddy floor with many rock fragments
10:44 1456 0.7 18 Sample #4a put in box 5 (talus) 4a
10:46 1456 0.5 22 Sample #4b put in box 5 (talus) 4b
10:48 1449 4.3 352 Big block and many small rock chips on the muddy floor
10:53 1423 2.8 359 Muddy floor with many rock fragments, debris
10:57 1407 5.4 323 Gravel floor covered with thin mud sediment
11:00 1404 1.4 354 Outcrop of weakly indurated breccia
11:00 1404 1.2 347 Sample #5a put in box 6 (from outcrop) 5a
11:02 1404 1.7 1 Sample #5b put in box 6 (from outcrop) 5b
11:04 1404 1.7 6 Attempting red push core in breccia matrix PC 3
11:08 1376 1.7 356 Gravel floor covered with thin mud sediment
11:12 1360 2.1 359 Muddy floor with many rock fragments
11:17 1337 1.3 0 Many rock fragments on the talus
11:20 1329 0.8 359 Sample #6a put in box 7 (talus) 6a
11:21 1329 0.9 6 Sample #6b put in box 7 (talus) 6b
11:25 1302 1.7 359 Gravel floor covered with thin mud sediment
11:27 1286 1.9 27 Outcrop shear zone, the edge of cliff, the slope is steep down leftward,
11:34 1288 1.9 42 Sample #7 put in box 1. Light colored material from soft rib 7
11:40 1254 3.9 17 Outcrop? the slope is steep down leftward
11:42 1231 3.8 25 Big block on the gravel floor
11:44 1229 2.2 41 Debris
11:45 1230 1.7 64 Samples #8a and #8b put in box 8 (from breccia outcrop) 8a, 8b
11:49 1220 2.3 32 Gravel floor
11:51 1191 2.8 2 Debris flow
11:53 1180 0.6 26 Muddy /sandy talus with some blocks,
11:56 1172 1.4 1 Edge of the talus, steep slope down leftward
12:00 1154 1.5 1 Debris flow
12:05 1142 1.3 0 Many rock fragments ,the slope is down leftward
12:10 1132 1.1 11 Many rock fragments on the talus
12:15 1104 1 1 Very uniform talus field, descending to the left. No sediment cover
12:16 1100 1.4 12 Sample #9a put in box 3 (from talus field) 9a
12:19 1101 1.6 28 Sample #9b put in box 3 (from talus field) 9b
12:21 1090 1.8 2 Debris flow. many rock fragments
12:27 1084 0.5 0 Many small rock fragments, the slope is down leftward
12:32 1071 1.4 0 Many small rock fragments, the slope is down leftward
12:37 1046 1.6 0 Many rock fragments, the slope is down leftward
12:44 1035 2.4 113 Sample #10a put in box 9 (from white band) 10a
12:46 1034 2.4 115 Sample #10b put in box 9 (from white band) 10b
12:49 1034 1.5 164 Slump
12:53 1011 0.7 6 Many small rock fragments on the slope, rocks are well sorted
12:57 999 1.2 2 Many small rock fragments, the slope is down leftward
13:02 964 5.6 355 Many small rock fragments, the slope is down leftward
13:06 962 0.8 341 Yellowish outcrop
13:08 962 1.1 356 Sample #11 put in box 7 (clast from whitish rib) 11
13:09 962 1.3 358 Yellow push core in white rib PC 4
13:13 951 4.5 2 Yellow block has jointing texture
13:16 950 0.5 1 Black sandy floor
13:20 943 0.7 12 Many rocks on the sandy floor
13:25 931 2.5 359 Many rocks on the sandy floor
13:29 927 2.1 2 Many rocks on the sandy floor
13:33 915 1.6 0 Some rounded rock fragments in debris flow
13:37 905 1.9 1 Debris flow
13:42 889 1.5 4 Sample #12a put in box 1 (talus) 12a
13:44 889 1.5 4 sample #12b put in box 1 (talus) 12b
13:45 889 1.5 4 Sample #12c put in box 1 (talus) 12c
13:47 875 0.5 1 Some rounded rock fragments in debris flow
13:51 864 1.1 9 Edge of the talus, steep slope down forward
13:52 Moving over the cliff
13:54 856 2.9 10 Some rounded rock fragments on debris flow
13:58 855 2.2 9 Debris flow
14:02 840 2.1 10 Sandy floor with rock fragments
14:08 828 1.9 9 Debris flow
14:15 807 2.2 9 Debris flow with big block
14:20 796 1.4 13 Sandy floor with rock fragments
14:22 792 1.4 11 Many rock fragments with sand
14:30 788 1.8 12 Many rock fragments with sand
14:32 784 1.4 9 Debris flow
14:35 777 1.5 9 Debris flow
14:37 770 2.2 11 Debris flow
14:41 751 2.7 10 Debris flow
14:43 742 2.4 11 On summit, sandy floor with small rock chips
14:46 744 1.7 26 Sample #13a put in box 4 13a
14:53 743 1.6 30 Sample #13b put in box 4 13b
14:56 742 1.4 28 Sample #13c put in box 4 13c
14:57 742 3.8 45 Leave bottom

home