A FIELD CONFERENCE ON IMPACTS OF COALBED METHANE DEVELOPMENT
IN THE POWDER RIVER BASIN, WYOMING
by
Romeo M. Flores, Gary D. Stricker, Joseph
F. Meyer, Thomas E. Doll,
Pierce H. Norton, Jr., Robert J. Livingston,
and M. Craig Jennings
Digital products by Scott Kinney, Heather Mitchell,
and Steve Dunn
Open-File Report 01-126
2001
This report is preliminary and has not been reviewed for
conformity with the U.S. Geological Survey editorial standards or with
the North American Stratigraphic Code. Any use of trade names is
for descriptive purposes only and does not imply endorsement by the U.S.
Government.
Field Trip Log from Midwest-Edgerton
to Wright-Reno Junction, Wyoming: 51 miles (by R.M. Flores)
Follow Highway 387 from Midwest through Edgerton, which
is on the Cody Shale (mile marker and associated Shannon Sandstone (mile
marker 100.5; see Fig. 3). The origin of the sandstone is controversial
and has been interpreted to be shelf ridge, lowstand facies tract (erosional-based
shoreface), and paleovalley (tidal bars, estuarine) sand bodies (Bergman
and Snedden, 1999).
The Shannon Sandstone is an important oil and gas reservoirs
in the Heldt Draw Field in the west-central part of the Powder River Basin
(Todd Davis, 1976; Spearing, 1976). As many as three sandstones (silty
and fine-grained) serve as stratigraphic traps for hydrocarbons.
The coal-bearing Parkman Sandstone of the Mesaverde Formation
(see Fig. 3) is exposed immediately north of Edgerton (mile marker 103).
In the next 12 miles, we begin a gradual ascent from the Upper Cretaceous
section (see Fig. 3) of the Cody Shale through the Mesaverde Formation
(mile marker 102.5-103.8), Lewis Shale (mile marker 105-107), Fox Hills
Sandstone (mile marker 109), and Lance Formation (mile marker 110-112).
The Lance Formation is coal bearing and is conformably overlain by the
Paleocene Fort Union and overlying Eocene Wasatch Formations. Coals
of the Fort Union Formation are the principal coalbed methane producing
beds in the Powder River Basin. A few coal beds in the Wasatch Formation
also produce coalbed methane.
After leaving the Lance Formation, we cross the Pine Ridge
(mile marker 113.2), which marks sandstone outcrops of the Fort Union Formation.
Pine trees commonly grow on these sandstones, which serve as aquifers.
Descend into the drainage basin of the Powder River that drains the south-central
part of the basin and flows to the northeast joining the Yellowstone River
in southeast Montana, which in turn, drains into the Missouri River.
In the next 36 miles to Wright-Reno Junction, the basin
is covered by the Wasatch Formation, which is overlain by the Oligocene
White River Formation (see Fig. 3), exposed in the Pumpkin Buttes to the
north. The White River Formation consists of volcaniclastic sandstones,
siltstones, conglomerates, and tuffaceous rocks. Uranium occurrences
in the Pumpkin Buttes were first reported by Love (1952). In 1954
two major areas in the southern part of the Powder River Basin were identified
to contain potential uranium resources: 1) Pumpkin Buttes-Turnercrest area
in parts of Johnson, Campbell, and Converse Counties, and 2) Monument Hill-Box
Creek area in Converse County (Curry and Crews 1976). Uranium ores
in the form of uraninite occur in permeable arkosic fluvial channel sandstones
in the uppermost part of the Fort Union and Wasatch Formations (see Fig.
3). The ores were formed as roll front deposits resulting from a
geochemical front that precipitated the minerals along a facies change
of coarse to fine clastic sediments (Buturla and Schwenk (1976).
Grasslands that mainly support cattle ranching cover the
Powder River Basin. The creeks that run through these grasslands
are intermittently dry. In this part of the basin land use is mainly
agricultural and range land. The majority of the surface here is
privately owned (e.g., Iberlin, Moore, and Taylor Ranches). About
55 percent of the subsurface minerals, such as coal, in the Powder River
Basin are Federally owned and managed by the U.S. Bureau of Land Management
(Fig. 4). The rest of the subsurface mineral ownership is State or
private.
The southernmost extent of Powder River Basin CBM development
in Campbell County occurs immediately south and north of Highway 387 and
east of Highway 50 (mile marker 123-147; Fig. 5). The Fort Union
coal beds (Fig. 6) that are producing coalbed methane in this part of the
Powder River Basin are shown in a composite stratigraphic column and a
series of north-south and east-west cross sections (Figs. 7-11).
Figures 8, 9, 10 and 11 show the thick coal beds of the Wyodak-Anderson
coal zone (sometimes informally named as Big George and Sussex coal zones),
which produce coalbed methane. These coal beds mainly occur from
1,000 to 2,000 ft below the surface (Fig. 12). The CBM well spacing
in the Powder River Basin varies from 40 (16 wells per section) to 80 (8
wells per section) acres. The Wyoming Oil and Gas Conservation Commission
recently issued an order of 80-acre spacing basinwide unless a gas operator
requests and justifies an exception of this well spacing.
Five CBM fields are being developed along Highway 387
(see Fig. 5). These fields include from southwest to northeast (towards
Wright), the Pine Tree (mile marker 123-129; Devon Energy Corporation),
Allnight Creek (mile marker 137.6-143.4; Barrett Resources Corporation),
K Bar (Yates Petroleum Company), House Creek (mile marker 146-146.7; Devon
Energy Corporation), and North Wright (Barrett Resources Corporation).
The Pine Tree and House Creek fields are both conventional oil and gas,
and CBM fields. These CBM fields were discovered in 1997 and are
the youngest to be developed in the Powder River Basin. The oldest
CBM fields (e.g., Marquiss) occur between Wright and Gillette and Highways
59 and 50 (Fig. 13). In that area, development began in the early
1990’s in the old Lighthouse and Marquiss coalbed methane project areas.
Since then development rapidly expanded from that project area in all directions,
but especially toward the north, west, and south. These areas
of early development by Barrett Resources Corporation and Lance Oil and
Gas Company (Western Gas) were identified by the U.S. Bureau of Land Management
(BLM) as the Gillette South Assessment Area (Bureau of Land Management,
1999). That area and an area of additional development in the Gillette
North Assessment Area located in central Campbell and northern Converse
Counties, within the eastern Powder River Basin were named by BLM as the
Wyodak CBM project Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) area (see Figs.
1 and 2). During the last several years, development has extended
westward outside the Wyodak CBM (EIS) project area.
The amount of methane produced from all wells and from
wells on federal leases in billions of cubic feet of gas (BCFG)/month as
well as the average amount of gas per well per day in thousand cubic feet
of gas (MCFG) from January, 1990 to October, 2000 is shown in Figure 14.
The number of wells in production over the same time period is shown in
Figure 15. As of October 30, 2000, the total CBM production was about
15 billion cubic feet of gas or bcf/month and the rate was about 120 MCF/day/well.
CBM production from Federal leases was about 2.5 bcfg/month at a rate of
25 MCF/day/well (see Fig. 14). A rapid increase of CBM production
occurred last year (2000). This increase may be explained by the
astronomical rise of producing wells of about 3,000 wells, in one year
(see Fig. 15). The range in depth of producing CBM wells is from
less than 200 to greater than 2,200 ft (see Fig. 16). Fifty percent
of the CBM producing wells have depths ranging from 400 to 800 ft.
Water co-produced with coalbed methane in the Powder River Basin, Wyoming
is shown in Figure 17. As of October 30, 2000, the total co-produced
water was about 37 million barrels/month at a rate of about 370 barrels
per day per well. Co-produced water from Federal leases is about
4 million barrels/month at a rate of about 400 barrels per day per well.
During the ten-year period from January, 1990 to January, 2000) the rate
of production, water ranged from 30 to 480 barrels per day per well.
However, one well in the west-central part of the basin produced as much
as 4,800 barrels of water per day.
|