Evaluation of Evidence Supporting the Effectiveness of Desert Tortoise Recovery Actions
By William I. Boarman1 and William B. Kristan2
Scientific Investigations Report 2006-5143, published 2006.
Table 6
Possible threats to desert tortoises (from Boarman 2002), strength of the supporting evidence, and best-supported possible impacts. [OHV, off-highway vehicle; NA, not available]
Individual threatsStrength of evidenceBest supported possible impact
AgricultureWeakHabitat loss
CollectingWeakDirect mortality1
ConstructionStrongHabitat loss, burrow damage, direct mortality
DiseaseWeakDirect mortality
DroughtWeak2Dehydration, predation3
Energy and mineral developmentsStrongHabitat loss, direct mortality during construction
FireStrongHabitat loss, habitat degradation, direct mortality
Garbage and litterWeakDirect mortality
Handling and deliberate manipulationWeakWater loss
Invasive plantsStrongHabitat degradation4
LandfillsStrongDirect mortality5
Livestock grazingStrongDirect mortality6, burrow damage7, habitat degradation8, food competition
Military operationsStrongHabitat loss, direct mortality
OHVStrongReduced tortoise density, habitat degradation, direct mortality, soil compaction, soil erosion
Predation/raven predation/subsidized predatorsStrong5Direct mortality
Non-OHV recreation9NANA
Roads, highways, and railroadsStrongHabitat loss, habitat degradation, direct mortality, population fragmentation
Utility corridorsStrongHabitat loss, direct mortality, increased predation risk10
VandalismStrong11Direct mortality
Wild horses and burrowsUnstudied 
1 Removal of animals from the population (functional mortality, if not actual mortality). 2 Tortoises are expected to be adapted to drought, but it may make them more susceptible to other stressors.3 Coyotes may increase predation on tortoises as preferred prey become less common.4 That grasses are less nutritious than forbs is well established, but the effects of introduced grasses on tortoise habitat quality and population size is less well studied.5 Increased raven numbers and increased risk of raven predation are well-established. Consequences of raven predation to tortoise population size are less well-studied.6 Few mortalities observed, but damage to styrofoam tortoise models indicates rates can be high.7 Rates of burrow damage depended on tortoise size, with juvenile and immature burrows more susceptible to damage than adult burrows.8 Changes in soils and in vegetation structure and composition.9 Largely unstudied as a group, though several possible activities (such as target shooting) are included in other categories.10 Transmission towers may facilitate raven population growth in areas previously lacking nesting substrates.11 That tortoises are killed is well supported, but the population-level consequences are not known.