Four lithotypes (vitrain, bright clarain, clarain, and fusain) of a high volatile bituminous Springfield Coal from the Illinois Basin were characterized using advanced solid-state ¹³C nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy. The NMR techniques included quantitative direct polarization/magic angle spinning (DP/MAS), cross polarization/total sideband suppression (CP/TOSS), dipolar dephasing, CH_n selection, and recoupled C–H long-range dipolar dephasing techniques. The lithotypes that experienced high-pressure CO₂ adsorption isotherm analysis were also analyzed to determine possible changes in coal structure as a result of CO₂ saturation at high pressure and subsequent evacuation. The main carbon functionalities present in original vitrain, bright clarain, clarain and fusain were aromatic carbons (65.9%–86.1%), nonpolar alkyl groups (9.0%–28.9%), and aromatic C–O carbons (4.1%–9.5%). Among these lithotypes, aromaticity increased in the order of clarain, bright clarain, vitrain, and fusain, whereas the fraction of alkyl carbons decreased in the same order. Fusain was distinct from other three lithotypes in respect to its highest aromatic composition (86.1%) and remarkably small fraction of alkyl carbons (11.0%). The aromatic cluster size in fusain was larger than that in bright clarain. The lithotypes studied responded differently to high pressure CO₂ saturation. After exposure to high pressure CO₂, vitrain and fusain showed a decrease in aromaticity but an increase in the fraction of alkyl carbons, whereas bright clarain and clarain displayed an increase in aromaticity but a decrease in the fraction of alkyl carbons. Aromatic fused-rings were larger for bright clarain but smaller for fusain in the post-CO₂ adsorption samples compared to the original lithotypes. These observations suggested chemical CO₂–coal interactions at high pressure and the selectivity of lithotypes in response to CO₂ adsorption.