Given a scarcity of commercial-scale carbon capture and storage (CCS) projects, there is a great deal of uncertainty in the risks, liability, and their cost implications for geologic storage of carbon dioxide (CO₂). The probabilities of leakage and the risk of induced seismicity could be remote, but the volume of geologic CO₂ storage (GCS) projected to be necessary to have a significant impact on increasing CO₂ concentrations in the atmosphere is far greater than the volumes of CO₂ injected thus far. National-level estimates of the technically accessible CO₂storage resource (TASR) onshore in the United States are on the order of thousands of gigatons of CO₂ storage capacity, but such estimates generally assume away any pressure management issues. Pressure buildup in the storage reservoir is expected to be a primary source of risk associated with CO₂ storage, and only a fraction of the theoretical TASR could be available unless the storage operator extracts the saltwater brines or other formation fluids that are already present in the geologic pore space targeted for CO₂ storage. Institutions, legislation, and processes to manage the risk, liability, and economic issues with CO₂ storage in the United States are beginning to emerge, but will need to progress further in order to allow a commercial-scale CO₂ storage industry to develop in the country. The combination of economic tradeoffs, property rights definitions, liability issues, and risk considerations suggests that CO₂ storage offshore of the United States may be more feasible than onshore, especially during the current (early) stages of industry development.