The Garrison camp comprises four structurally distinct orogenic gold deposits that formed in different host lithologies during progressive deformation. Detailed field mapping, drill core logging, and geochronological constraints suggest that the 2678 ± 2 Ma Garrison granitic stock played a fundamental rheological role in the location of the four deposits. Initial local shear movement occurred along the southwestern margin of the stock leading to the development of the NW-trending sinistral NE-side-up Buffonta shear zone, which hosts the Buffonta deposit. Subsequently, a transtensional zone formed between the NE-trending sinistral Porcupine-Destor and Munro deformation zones, which host the 903 and Jonpol deposits, respectively. Finally, a local change in shortening orientation from NE to NNW caused westerly directed extension resulting in the formation of the younger gold-bearing veins composing the Garrcon deposit. In situ U-Pb laser ablation-inductively coupled plasma-mass spectrometry performed on monazite grains formed within the shear fabric of the Munro deformation zone indicates that transtension occurred at 2657 ± 15 Ma. Therefore, at least three of the four deposits formed subsequent to crystallization of the Garrison granitic stock. The reported U-Pb dates represent the first direct age constraints on the movement along a gold-bearing deformation zone in the southern Abitibi greenstone belt.