Gars (Lepisosteidae) are increasingly being managed as top-level predators that are important to overall ecosystem health. Given the paucity of information on early life history for many species, additional early life history data would aid in gar conservation and management. Daily rings in otoliths are useful for determining many early life history parameters, such as growth rates and the date of hatch, but properly interpreting these structures requires additional information on otolith formation. Gars represent an ancient lineage, and their otoliths are unlike those of most teleost fishes, having multiple nuclei and being covered on the surface with very small otoconia. We used computed tomography X-ray scanning and oxytetracycline (OTC) marking of a series of known-age fish from hatch through 10–12 d posthatch (dph) to understand the formation of otoliths in the Spotted Gar Lepisosteus oculatus, a species that is of management concern in several parts of its range in North America. The sagittae and lapilli each began as loose associations of otoconia at hatch; they fused and hardened into single crystals by 4 dph, in concert with the transition from attached larvae to free-swimming juveniles. Asteriscus otoliths were not observed in any of the individuals examined through 12 dph. The OTC marks were not observed on individuals treated at hatch, and variable marks were detected at 1–5 dph. By 6 dph, 100% of individuals exhibited OTC marks on sagittae and lapilli. Daily rings could not be discerned until fish were marked at 4 dph, after which daily age estimates increased linearly with fish age. Results of this study verify that in Spotted Gars, otoliths (sagittae and lapilli) and their daily rings form several days after hatch, in relation to the transition from sessile, attached larvae to free-swimming juveniles.