Effects of elk and bison herbivory on narrowleaf cottonwood

Western North American Naturalist
By:  and 



Ungulate browsing influences the structure and composition of woody plant communities, including species composition and biomass production as well as age distribution, recruitment, and mortality. We evaluated effects of elk and bison herbivory on narrowleaf cottonwood (Populus angustifolia) communities in a semiarid ecosystem in southern Colorado. Cottonwoods in this ecosystem have been aged at ≥300 years old and are among the oldest cottonwood trees in North America. We compared browsing intensity and structural and productivity responses of cottonwood to ungulate herbivory. We compared responses in sites with elk and bison, sites with elk but no bison, and sites where both ungulates were excluded. We found that the majority of browsing on cottonwood occurred during summer in this high desert ecosystem. Areas with both elk and bison had higher browse utilization than areas with only elk, but diet data indicated that elk consumed a much greater proportion of cottonwood than bison. Overall, browse utilization observed in this study was low to moderate compared to other studies, and our results may not be representative of sites experiencing intense year-round herbivory. Removal of all ungulate herbivory led to taller and denser cottonwood suckers; however, other environmental factors, in addition to herbivory, still strongly limit cottonwood growth and recruitment in this ecosystem.

Study Area

Publication type Article
Publication Subtype Journal Article
Title Effects of elk and bison herbivory on narrowleaf cottonwood
Series title Western North American Naturalist
DOI 10.3398/064.081.0109
Volume 81
Issue 1
Year Published 2021
Language English
Publisher Brigham Young University
Contributing office(s) Fort Collins Science Center
Description 16 p.
First page 97
Last page 112
Country United States
State Colorado
Other Geospatial Great Sand Dunes ecosystem of the San Luis Valley
Google Analytic Metrics Metrics page
Additional publication details