Field and laboratory studies of the 1959 Kīlauea Iki lava lake have provided insight into differentiation processes in mafic magma chambers. This paper explores how partially molten basaltic mushes responded to unloading as a consequence of drilling. Most holes drilled from 1967 to 1979 terminated in a melt-rich internal differentiate with a sharp crust-melt interface. These interfaces were not stable, so the boreholes were backfilled by melt-rich (<5% crystal) ooze. This process, with melt ascent rates of 1.3–4.2 m/s, occurred within minutes of intersecting the bodies, mimicking volcanic eruptions, albeit on a small scale.

One borehole (KI79-1), which did not encounter such a discontinuity, was backfilled over a period of 16 days by upward flow of crystal-rich mushes rather than melt-rich ooze. The first interval of ooze recovered had undergone extensive internal differentiation. Its most conspicuous feature was production of melt-rich layers by lateral migration of interstitial melt from the wallrock into the rising crystal-rich mush. In addition, two smaller-scale processes occurred within the rising mush: segregation of melt into discrete blebs within the rising mush column and aggregation of groundmass crystals into crystal-rich clumps formed adjacent to coarser olivine crystals. The upper parts of the ooze are enriched in melt relative to deeper samples, which suggests that the melt blebs rose relative to their olivine-rich matrix. Similar melt blebs and crystal-rich clumps are observed in naturally occurring diapiric bodies within the lava lake. These processes appear to be intrinsic to the upwelling of narrow cylindrical mush bodies whether constrained within a borehole (like the oozes) or unconstrained (as were the diapirs in the lava lake).

The most striking behavior observed during repeated reentry of KI79-1 was a sharp change in rheology during the second and third re-entries of the borehole. The shift in behavior observed was that the oozes rose up the borehole, with ascent rates of 1.0–1.7 m/s, which are comparable to the rates of the crystal-poor oozes from melt-rich internal differentiates. These oozes contain more melt than the original core at equivalent depths, presumably because melt moved relative to crystals down the pressure gradient created by the open borehole. Groundmass textures in these inflated mushes show erosion of crystal outlines, especially of grain-to-grain contacts between different phases, so that the tenuous crystalline network observed in the original core samples was replaced by rounded crystals in continuous melt at crystallinities of 55–65 vol%. The transition from stable coherent mush to inflatable mush occurred at 25–28 vol% melt. This behavior appears similar to certain types of reactive transport observed in other studies.