The Hawkeye Granite Gneiss and Lyon Mountain Granite Gneiss are widespread Mesoproterozoic plutonic rocks that occur in the amphibolite- to granulite-facies Adirondack Highlands of northern New York, USA. The strongly deformed Hawkeye Granite Gneiss, previously dated by zircon multi-grain thermal ionization mass spectrometry (TIMS) U-Pb analyses at about 1100 Ma, was intruded by the weakly deformed Lyon Mountain Granite Gneiss. Previous sensitive high resolution ion microprobe (SHRIMP) analyses of Lyon Mountain Granite Gneiss zircon rims were considered to record the time of igneous emplacement at about 1.05 Ga, whereas the ages of zircon cores (~1.15 Ga) were interpreted as being inherited from nearby metaigneous country rocks. This interpretation has formed the basis of numerous models for the Mesoproterozoic structural and tectonic evolution of the Adirondacks Highlands. New U-Pb spot analyses (~15-20 µm diameter) by SHRIMP from four samples of Hawkeye Granite Gneiss and eight samples of Lyon Mountain Granite Gneiss challenge the historically accepted ages of the rocks. Using a combination of high-resolution CL imagery of oscillatory zoned cores and weakly zoned to unzoned rims, SHRIMP U-Pb geochronology, SHRIMP trace element geochemistry, and SEM petrography, we conclude that: (1) the Hawkeye Granite Gneiss was emplaced at about 1160 to 1155 Ma; (2) the vast majority of Lyon Mountain Granite Gneiss zircon cores yield ages of 1150 to 1145 Ma and are mainly primary, not inherited; and (3) the Hawkeye Granite Gneiss and Lyon Mountain Granite Gneiss zircon rims (~1080 to 1000 Ma) are metamorphic in origin, not igneous. Thus, both the Hawkeye Granite Gneiss and Lyon Mountain Granite Gneiss are considered herein to be late members of the mangerite-charnockite-granite (MCG) plutonic suite, emplaced during the waning stages of the Shawinigan orogeny. Zircon cores from two small plutons of largely undeformed fayalite granite of the Lyon Mountain Granite Gneiss are about 1142 Ma, providing a minimum age constraint for the termination of the Shawinigan. Zircon rim ages can be deconvoluted into multiple metamorphic events of the Ottawan and Rigolet tectonothermal events. These new interpretations have profound implications for structural, tectonic, and ore deposit models of the Adirondacks Highlands.