Advances in tracking technology are greatly improving our understanding of many aspects of avian ecology. However, the diversity of tracking devices and attachment methods necessitates better evaluation of how they affect particular taxa. We evaluated effects of tracking devices mounted on leg bands or attached using leg-loop harnesses on resighting rates of Black Oystercatchers Haematopus bachmani in Alaska and British Columbia. In Alaska, in 2019, geolocators were mounted on a leg band (n = 20) or encased in a nylon mount and attached using a leg-loop harness (n = 20), and GPS devices were attached using a leg-loop harness (n = 6). In British Columbia, Argos-PTT satellite transmitters were attached using a leg-loop harness (n = 26) in 2019 and 2020. Control birds were colour-banded (Alaska: n = 22; British Columbia: n = 27) but were not equipped with a tracking device. Surveys to resight birds with and without tracking devices were conducted in 2020 and 2021. Birds carrying geolocators, GPS devices, and Argos-PTT satellite transmitters attached using a leg-loop harness were as likely to be resighted (69% in Alaska and 62% in British Columbia) as control birds (59% in both areas). However, birds carrying geolocators mounted on leg bands were far less likely to be resighted (15%). We also used resighting data and a time-to-tag failure analysis to obtain a minimum annual survival estimate for the birds carrying an Argos-PTT satellite transmitter. The minimum annual survival estimate for these birds (0.81 ± 0.08 SE) did not differ from previously reported annual apparent survival estimates for Black Oystercatchers in British Columbia (0.91 ± 0.02 SE). These findings suggest that while Black Oystercatchers can successfully carry tracking devices weighing less than 3% of their body mass when attached using a leg-loop harness, they are negatively affected by small tracking devices mounted directly on leg bands.