The San Luis Valley in Colorado, USA, an agriculturally dominated stopover area, is used by the Rocky Mountain population of Antigone canadensis tabida (Greater Sandhill Crane) and some midcontinental individuals of A. c. canadensis (Lesser Sandhill Crane) during migration. While the numbers of both subspecies are stable, the effects of continued water scarcity and declines in grain output on the energetics of cranes in the San Luis Valley are unclear. We conducted roadside counts of A. c. tabida and A. c. canadensis on agricultural fields to determine the effects of crop type, roost distance, and tillage intensity on their selection and abundance on crop fields. Antigone canadensis varied in their use of the San Luis Valley for foraging. In autumn, both subspecies selected barley and other grains over other crop types. In spring, cranes preferred to forage in barley fields, and selection declined as distance to roosts increased. Both subspecies also selected barley fields that were lightly or not tilled. We modeled covariates on abundance for A. c. tabida only and found that more cranes were found close to roosts early in the season in autumn. As the season progressed, the number of A. c. tabida increased as roost distance increased. In spring, abundance was influenced by an interaction between time and crop, with the highest numbers found on barley and pasture around mid-March. Our results suggest that A. canadensis may switch to other crop types as resources are depleted near roosts but appear to prefer to fly farther for grains. Grains that are left idle or moderately tilled and are located near roosts will help ensure A. canadensis are able to maintain adequate nutrient reserves at agriculturally dominated stopover areas during migration.