Aechmophorus occidentalis (Western Grebe) are colonial nesting waterbirds that have experienced population declines. We located and monitored 709 grebe nests using a drone within Lake Cascade, the largest grebe breeding colony in Idaho. We conducted 6 flights between June 20, 2018 and July 11, 2018 and used the photographs from each flight to create an orthomosaic image that we then digitized and georeferenced. The resolution of the images allowed for visualization of each nest, nest contents, and adult grebes on each flight. Using the georeferenced images, we created nest histories and estimated nest fate for the 709 grebe nests. We also collected data on the following covariates to assess whether any of them affected nest survival: distance of the nest to the center of the colony; distance of the nest to the edge of the colony; distance of the nest to deep water habitat; water depth at the nest; nearest neighbor distance, and an aggregation index (mean distance to the 5 nearest nests). The orthomosaics from repeated drone flights allowed us to estimate nesting success without disturbing the colony; 51.2% of nests survived until hatching. The daily survival probability of grebe nests was positively correlated with the aggregation index and water depth at the nest (albeit only slightly). Daily survival probabilities were negatively correlated with distance between the nest and the colony center and distance to deep water (i.e., foraging habitat). The results of this study can be used to inform conservation efforts by identifying areas of the Lake Cascade grebe colony that are most vulnerable to nest failures and formulating explicit management actions that could be implemented to increase nest survival such as changes in timing of water drawdowns and habitat management to ensure habitat suitable for grebe nesting is in close proximity to deep water foraging areas. Moreover, grebes are not the only waterbird that makes use of managed reservoirs; other waterbirds may benefit from the findings of this study to implement more informed management practices.