At Redwood National and State parks restoration efforts are underway to promote the recovery of forests following a history of intense logging. Unmanaged secondary forests at the parks have high stem density with slow stand development. Restoration thinning treatments of these stands are designed to promote the representation of redwood and improve the growth of residual trees. Restoration treatments, by definition, remove live tree carbon, so there is a potential conflict with restoration and carbon sequestration goals. We used data from 151 monitoring plots to determine early treatment effects (mostly ≤ 10 years following treatments) on live tree forest carbon in thinned and unthinned stands. Aboveground live tree carbon in untreated secondary forests was primarily related to stand age. Both treated and untreated stands accumulated carbon over time, with evidence that treated stands had a slightly faster rate of carbon accumulation. For a subset of plots where we had sufficient replicates of thinning prescriptions, we found thinning resulted in reductions in live tree aboveground carbon, particularly for heavy thinning, but with plots accumulating live tree carbon stocks similar to pre-treatment levels within 6–10 years. Stand projections suggested that both thinned and unthinned stands have the capacity to greatly increase aboveground live tree carbon in coming decades, with thinned stands accumulating aboveground live tree carbon at a slightly faster pace.