Planktic foraminiferal species distributions in the modern ocean track environmental features like sea surface temperature (SST). Species shift their distributions as the marine environment changes, providing an analogue for past behaviour. Stationarity of species' ecological tolerances is therefore a first-order assumption of all palaeoenvironmental reconstructions based upon modern analogue methods. In this paper we test the hypothesis that planktic foraminifer species temperature preferences did not change between the Late Pliocene and present, using a dataset which contains faunal abundance data and alkenone palaeotemperature data from the same samples. Our dataset includes 463 samples from 29 localities. Pliocene relative abundances of four taxa (Globigerina bulloides, Globigerinita glutinata, Neogloboquadrina pachyderma and Neogloboquadrina incompta) are compared to SST estimates of the same age derived using the alkenone unsaturation ratio (U^K'₃₇) palaeothermometer. Core-top abundances of the same taxa were compared to pre-industrial SST. Our Pliocene data are generally concordant with previous work. Pliocene SST responses and those of the pre-industrial are similar, supporting the hypothesis that temperature preferences of planktic foraminifera have been relatively stable since the Late Pliocene. This documentation of stationarity of planktic foraminiferal species' temperature tolerances is helpful in identifying situations where environmental variables other than temperature (e.g. salinity or productivity) exhibit a first-order control on faunal diversity. Our results support the notion of taxonomic uniformitarianism and therefore provide additional confidence in using planktic foraminifera to evaluate both regional and global climate change.