The ages and sizes at which organisms mature have significant implications for lifetime reproductive success. For species at risk of extinction, such as sea turtles, these attributes can ultimately impact probability of population persistence. Within the Northwest Atlantic Ocean, the broader loggerhead sea turtle (Caretta caretta) population comprises management units both along the US Gulf of America (formerly Gulf of Mexico) and Atlantic coasts. Although age, growth, and maturation have been more intensively studied along the US Atlantic, data specific to the Gulf of America have remained sparse. To address this data gap, we conducted skeletal growth mark analysis (skeletochronology) for 123 humerus bones collected from loggerheads found dead in the US Gulf of America from 1998 to 2021. We compared resulting age, growth, and maturation data with information from studies of US Atlantic coast loggerheads for similar size and year ranges, using the exact same skeletochronology methods, as well as with Gulf of America mark-recapture growth data. Results indicate that Gulf of America loggerheads exhibit significantly faster juvenile somatic growth. In addition, sizes at maturation were substantially smaller, corresponding with mean estimates of age at maturation 7.5 to 15 years earlier than US Atlantic counterparts. Finally, the maximum observed Gulf of America adult age estimate was 42.5 years, considerably less than the highest US Atlantic estimate of 77.0 years. These detailed data offer insights into regional variability in somatic growth dynamics and characteristics associated with maturation, which in turn can impact relative reproductive contributions and, ultimately, population trajectories.