Many mesocarnivores have low detection rates that hinder practitioners' abilities to implement effective monitoring strategies. Using olfactory attractants (i.e. lures) may increase detection rates, but variation in effects among species is not well understood. Thus, investigating factors influencing detection of mesocarnivores, can inform and improve monitoring efforts. We evaluated the effects of lures and environmental covariates on the detection of plains spotted skunks Spilogale interrupta, striped skunks Mephitis mephitis, northern raccoons Procyon lotor, gray foxes Urocyon cinereoargenteus, coyotes Canis latrans, bobcats Lynx rufus and Virginia opossums Didelphis virginiana. We conducted surveys during January–May 2023 in southeast Oklahoma using motion-triggered cameras at randomly selected sites. We surveyed sites using a 4-camera cluster and leave-one-out lure design, where 3 cameras were randomly assigned 1 of 4 lures (i.e. skunk-based lure, fatty acid tablets, sweet lure or sardines) and 1 camera was a control (i.e. no lure). We analyzed species-specific detection data within an occupancy framework to determine the influence of lure combinations and environmental covariates (i.e. temperature, precipitation and moon illumination) on site-level detection patterns for each species. When lures influenced detection, we assessed species-specific preference among lures (and the control) within sites by comparing camera-level independent detections with Kruskal–Wallis and Dunn's tests at sites where the species was detected. The effect of lures varied among species; lure combinations influenced site-specific daily detection of plains spotted skunks, striped skunks, gray foxes, raccoons and bobcats, but did not affect detection of coyotes or opossums. One environmental covariate influenced detection of striped skunks (i.e. moon illumination), bobcats (i.e. temperature), and gray foxes (i.e. precipitation). Within sites, lure preference varied among species. Spotted skunks, gray foxes and raccoons preferred sardines whereas striped skunks preferred the skunk-based lure. Identifying lure preferences and effects of environmental factors can help optimize sampling and improve mesocarnivore monitoring efforts.