Restoration of Gavia immer (Common Loon) in Minnesota—2022 Annual Report
The “Restoration of Common Loons in Minnesota” project is funded by the Open Ocean Trustee Implementation Group through the Natural Resource Damage Assessment Deepwater Horizon settlement. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service assisted in all activities reported here. We thank two anonymous reviewers who provided comments that improved this report.
The explosion of the Deepwater Horizon mobile drilling platform on April 20, 2010, caused a massive oil spill and injury to natural resources in the Gulf of Mexico. Gavia immer (common loon) were negatively affected from the spill. The Open Ocean Trustee Implementation Group funded the project “Restoration of Common Loons in Minnesota” to restore common loons lost to the spill. Here, we report on activities conducted for this project in an eight-county region in Minnesota in calendar year 2022. We identified a subset of territories that were monitored in 2021 as focal territories (n=99) from which multiyear study inferences can ultimately be made. We monitored nonfocal territories on all study lakes as well. We conducted surveys from May 9 to August 12, 2022. At least 1 nest attempt was observed in 68 of 99 focal territories, and a second nest attempt after a failed initial attempt was observed in 19 focal territories. Chicks or other evidence of hatching was observed in 33 of 99 territories. Data collected in 2021 and 2022 for this project are presented in a U.S. Geological Survey data release (https://doi.org/10.5066/P9LA536E). We present no formal data analysis in this report.
The Deepwater Horizon (DWH; fig. 1) oil spill caused extensive injury to natural resources in the Gulf of Mexico in 2010 (Deepwater Horizon Natural Resource Damage Assessment Trustees, 2016), and Gavia immer (common loon) was one of the species substantially affected by the oil spill (Beatty and others, 2022). The DWH Open Ocean Trustee Implementation Group funded the project “Restoration of Common Loons in Minnesota” to restore common loons lost from the spill. The project has three objectives that are detailed below (Open Ocean Trustee Implementation Group, 2019):
Acquire and protect critical lakeshore nesting and foraging habitat.
Enhance common loon habitat and increase lake stewardship.
Reduce lead exposure through advocacy of nontoxic fishing tackle.
This report describes activities under the project “Restoration of Common Loons in Minnesota” for calendar year 2022. The Monitoring and Adaptive Management Plan (Open Ocean Trustee Implementation Group, 2019) identified benchmarks to evaluate project progress and completion. Thus, we report progress on monitoring benchmarks defined in the Monitoring and Adaptive Management Plan. Furthermore, we include no formal data analysis but report summary statistics based on data collected in 2021 and 2022 for this project (Beatty and others, 2023).
In 2022, we conducted common loon monitoring for a second consecutive year to collect additional pretreatment data before artificial nest platform (ANP) deployment in 2023. We surveyed priority lakes from May 9 to August 12, 2022 (fig. 1; table 1). We provided a detailed description of the methods used to identify priority lakes in Beatty and others (2022). Briefly, we identified an eight-county study area to focus project activities (Beatty and others, 2022). We identified priority lakes from Minnesota Loon Watcher citizen science data (K. Larson, Minnesota Department of Natural Resources, written commun., 2020) to focus activities on lakes with low common loon reproductive rates. All priority lakes had less than or equal to (≤) 0.85 chicks hatched per pair or ≤0.7 fledged chicks per pair in August based on Minnesota Loon Watcher data (Beatty and others, 2022). Although we anticipated surveys would begin on May 2, 2022, many survey lakes had ice present the first week of May. Consequently, we surveyed all territories the week of May 9, 2022.
Table 1.Lakes in an eight-county region in north-central Minnesota that were surveyed to collect baseline information on common loon territory occupancy, nest success, and chick survival.
We provided a detailed description of the methods used to monitor loon territories in Beatty and others (2022). Briefly, we surveyed each lake by motorboat, kayak, canoe, or shoreline observation. We circumnavigated larger lakes with a motorboat and frequently stopped to scan for common loons with binoculars or the naked eye. We thoroughly searched small inlets, bays, coves, and areas around islands for common loons. We also collected information on environmental variables that could affect detection. We recorded all data from surveys in an ArcGIS Survey123 application. We visited loon territories every 3–18 days (mean=8.6 days, median=7 days) from May 9 to July 15 to document territory occupancy, monitor nests, and document chicks. We visited one territory (Daisy Lake) two days in a row because the first visit was conducted at dusk. We conducted chick survival surveys from August 1 to August 12, 2022; we visited each territory twice during this period.
In 2021, we monitored 126 territories on 55 lakes (fig. 1; table 1) throughout the study area, 16 of which contained an ANP, otherwise known as our intended future treatment, in 2021 (Beatty and others, 2022). Thus, Beatty and others (2022) reported monitoring 110 territories in 2021 that did not include an ANP because the goal of common loon monitoring in 2021 and 2022 was to collect pretreatment data from territories without ANPs. We conducted further revisions to our sample of focal territories in early 2022 before the 2022 field season commenced. We identified eight territories as multilake territories and re-categorized these as nonfocal territories because of uncertainty associated with the nesting location. Consequently, we identified 126–16–8=102 territories as focal territories for the study before field surveys commenced in 2022, and randomly assigned 45 of these territories to the treatment category with the remaining 57 territories assigned to the control category. Treatment territories represented sampling units that are planned to receive an ANP in 2023, whereas control territories would not receive an ANP for the duration of the study.
We observed a new ANP in three focal territories in 2022, and we re-categorized these territories to nonfocal territories (Crooked Lake, West Crooked East Bay territory; Crooked Lake, West Crooked West Bay territory; Thunder Lake, East Bay Island territory). We did not identify the responsible party for the new ANPs, but ANPs are typically deployed by landowners who have property on lakes. We identified six new territories in 2022, which were territories that were not detected in 2021. We identified new territories on Deer Lake (3), Crooked Lake (1), Goodrich Lake (1), and Stump Lake (1). We categorized these six new territories as nonfocal territories. Thus, we monitored 126+6=132 total territories in 2022, and we had a sample of 132–16–8–3–6=99 focal territories in 2022. We continued to monitor nonfocal territories to document loon dynamics on study lakes to better inform states of focal territories on the same lake.
In our sample of 99 focal territories, we observed an initial nest attempt in 68 territories and a second nest attempt in 19 territories. All second nest attempts were the result of a failed initial nest attempt. As in 2021, we considered a successful nest attempt as a territory where at least one chick was observed, or where other evidence of a successful nest was observed at the nest site (Beatty and others, 2022). In 2022, we observed a successful nest attempt in 33 of 99 focal territories.
Benchmarks to Evaluate Project Progress
The Monitoring and Adaptative Management Plan (Open Ocean Trustee Implementation Group, 2019) provides parameters for project progress, and we report on all parameters in the plan below. Data collected for this study in 2021 and 2022 are presented in Beatty and others (2023).
Parameter 1, Baseline Status of Lakes
We detailed the completion of parameter 1 in the 2021 annual report (Beatty and others, 2022).
Parameter 2, Length of Linear Shoreline Acquired
The Minnesota Department of Natural Resources (MN DNR) contracted Northern Waters Land Trust (NWLT) to identify potential parcels for consideration for acquisition. Contract costs were covered by State funds. NWLT compiled information on lakeshore owners in the focus area, screened for potential habitat at a broad spatial scale, distributed information on agency interest in acquiring loon habitat, assessed landowner interest in selling, and summarized interactions with landowners. NWLT findings were provided to MN DNR, and eight landowners expressed interest in either fee title acquisition or conservation easements on shoreline parcels that are considered loon nesting habitat. NWLT concluded outreach to evaluate landowner interest in acquisition on October 7, 2022. In addition, three landowners expressed interest in fee title acquisition or conservation easements through MN DNR Fisheries, and one landowner directly contacted MN DNR to express interest in the program.
Joint meetings among MN DNR, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS), and U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) staffs were held to discuss and rank the value of individual parcels to the project and to secure approval from USFWS for individual parcels to enter the internal MN DNR acquisition process. Five parcels were then discussed internally with MN DNR Fisheries and Wildlife staff and MN DNR Acquisition Program staff.
Parameter 3, Number of ANPs Deployed
We monitored 132 territories on 55 lakes (fig. 1) throughout the study area in 2022, including 99 focal territories, 8 multilake territories, 19 territories with an ANP, and 6 new territories. We randomly assigned 45 of 99 focal territories to the ANP treatment category. As of the end of calendar year 2022, MN DNR had commitments from 26 partners to construct and deploy 39 ANPs in spring 2023 on these treatment territories. MN DNR plans to continue working with potential partners to generate support for the remaining six ANPs. Thus, we deployed 0 of 45 (0 percent) of anticipated ANPs in 2022.
Parameter 4, Number of ANPs Occupied
We did not deploy ANPs in 2022. We plan to deploy ANPs spring 2023 in collaboration with lake associations and loon stewards. We have no values to report for the number of ANPs occupied.
Parameter 5, Number and Locations of Lake Associations Recruited
MN DNR recruited 72 lake associations in calendar year 2022 in the following counties: Aitkin (6), Becker (5), Beltrami (2), Cass (21), Clearwater (2), Crow Wing (11), Hubbard (24), and Itasca (3) (fig. 1). Lake associations were recruited to develop lake management plans that contain conservation actions for common loons.
Parameter 6, Number of Intervention Activities to Promote Use of Environmentally Friendly Fishing Gear
The Minnesota Pollution Control Agency’s “Get the Lead Out” program conducted 65 in-person education programs and 21 virtual programs in 2022. Education and outreach programs from the program ranged from presentations to K–12 students (both virtually and in person), ice fishing programs, visiting summer fishing day camps, tabling at community events, tabling at a sports show, and giving virtual presentations for lake association members and the public. In addition to all these activities, the program coordinated an exhibit about loons built around the World’s Largest Floating Loon from Virginia, Minn. The exhibit was included in the Eco-Experience building at the Minnesota State Fair and was seen by more than 200,000 people during the 12 days of the fair. Another component of all these outreach programs is giving sample packs of lead-free fishing tackle to the public. The program distributed an estimated 20,000 sample packs of lead-free tackle during 2022 to people across the State.
Parameter 7, Presence/Absence, Territory Occupancy and Nest Productivity
We monitored 99 focal territories on 55 lakes (fig. 1) in 2022. All territories had at least one loon present on at least one sampling occasion. We defined an occupied territory as a sampling unit that had a pair of loons present on at least three sampling occasions between May 9, 2022, and July 15, 2022, or an observation of a subsequent stage in the reproductive process. Two examples of these subsequent stages in the reproductive process include nesting and hatched chicks. We observed 95 of 99 territories as occupied in 2022 (Beatty and others, 2023).
Beatty, W.S., Fara, L.J., Houdek, S.C., Kenow, K.P., and Gray, B.R., 2022, Restoration of Gavia immer (common loon) in Minnesota—2021 annual report. U.S. Geological Survey Open-File Report 2022–1074, 7 p., accessed January 2023 at https://doi.org/10.3133/ofr20221074.
Beatty, W.S., Fara, L.J., Houdek, S.C., Kenow, K.P., and Gray, B.R., 2023, Summary of detection data for breeding common loons in north-central Minnesota (2021–2022): U.S. Geological Survey data release, https://doi.org/10.5066/P9LA536E.
Deepwater Horizon Natural Resource Damage Assessment Trustees, 2016, Deepwater Horizon oil spill—Final programmatic damage assessment and restoration plan and final programmatic environmental impact statement: Silver Spring, Md., National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, National Marine Fisheries Service, variously paged, accessed August 2023 at https://www.gulfspillrestoration.noaa.gov/restoration-planning/gulf-plan.
Open Ocean Trustee Implementation Group, 2019, Final restoration plan 1 and environmental assessment—Birds and sturgeon: Open Ocean Trustee Implementation Group, 124 p., accessed April 2022 at https://www.gulfspillrestoration.noaa.gov/2019/03/open-ocean-trustees-approve-final-restoration-plan-1.
For more information about this publication, contact:
Director, USGS Upper Midwest Environmental Sciences Center
2630 Fanta Reed Road
La Crosse, WI 54603
For additional information, visit: https://www.usgs.gov/centers/upper-midwest-environmental-sciences-center
Publishing support provided by the Rolla Publishing Service Center
Beatty, W.S., Fara, L.J., Houdek, S.C., Rabasco, R., Rettler, S., Rasmussen, E., Kenow, K.P., Gray, B.R., Yang, S., and Amoth, K., 2023, Restoration of Gavia immer (common loon) in Minnesota—2022 annual report: U.S. Geological Survey Open-File Report 2023–1062, 5 p., https://doi.org/10.3133/ofr20231062.
ISSN: 2331-1258 (online)
|Publication Subtype||USGS Numbered Series|
|Title||Restoration of Gavia immer (common loon) in Minnesota—2022 annual report|
|Series title||Open-File Report|
|Publisher||U.S. Geological Survey|
|Publisher location||Reston, VA|
|Contributing office(s)||Upper Midwest Environmental Sciences Center|
|Description||Report: vi, 5 p.; Data Release|
|Online Only (Y/N)||Y|
|Google Analytic Metrics||Metrics page|